If We Were Riding’ is a weekly triathlon-ish newsletter written by Kelly O’Mara and produced by Live Feisty Media. Subscribe to get it in your inbox every Wednesday morning. You can also read past issues. This episode is from May 8, 2019.

_______________

Apparently, I dated last week’s newsletter April 31, which isn’t even actually a day. How’s your week going?

Hello to all of you who said hi at St. George (and shout-out to Live Feisty right-hand-woman Jessica, who legit biked faster than me). I had a fine race. Not amazing, but fine, one I could bank and sometimes you just need one of those. It’s an insane course. And it was some super insane competition. More on that below.

And a reminder: There’ll be no new podcast this Friday. Use the time to catch up on all the past episodes.

________________

Which race was better?

(Photos: Gregory Shamus/Getty Images for Ironman (left); Sean Haffey/Getty Images for Ironman (right))

At St. George on Saturday, Holly Lawrence broke the course record by five minutes. By all appearances her performance was better than at Oceanside, where she said she had a rough day and was second to Daniela. But was it really? How do you know when one race is better or worse than another? How do you know how it stacks up? How do you compare it to other people also comparing their performance to other days?

(I am sure she would say St. George was definitively better. By the numbers. And she was flying all day. But how you feel isn’t always indicative of how you actually perform, right?)

The other thing about St. George this weekend was it was really fucking deep and competitive. Possibly the most competitive women’s field I’ve seen outside of a world championships. [The men’s field was also quite deep, but not as totally completely nuts.]

That meant I wasn’t the only person who finished and was like ‘wait, there were *how many* people ahead of me?’ It also meant the middle of the race calculus was even more complicated than usual: Most of the time I beat ‘x’ person and right now I’m behind them, but often I lose to ‘y’ girl and I’m staying steady with her. I always swim near so-and-so, but did they have a bad day today or am I on fire? How many minutes should I be ahead or behind? Is this good or bad? How do I know?

Here’s my idea: Given the big data we have in 2019, it should be possible to crunch the numbers and tell me how my swim stacked up compared to everyone else’s swims v. their previous averages. Thorsten, can you get on this? And tell us if Holly’s performance in St. G was better or worse than Daniela’s in Oceanside? kthnx.

More announcements

Well, I was at least mostly right: Ironman announced St. George will be the site of the 2021 70.3 World Championships. Which is sort of amazing, given how hard the course is. But it’s also sort of insane. That bike course isn’t exactly easy and triathletes aren’t generally exactly amazing bike handlers. I hit 45 mph at one point on course, and got a bit knocked around by the wind of oncoming traffic. Hopefully, no one dies.

The other half of Ironman’s announcement is that the full Ironman will come back to St. George next year as the North American IM champs (May 2020) and will rotate every three years. The gist is there will be three cities that will rotate a full and then have a 70.3 in the two off years. What will the other two cities be? Coeur d’Alene is probably a good guess. It’d be weird IMO for the new midwestern IM to be the third, but who knows. I thought maybe Whistler, but then Ironman made another announcement that an announcement was coming: IM Canada is moving back to Penticton after all that fighting over who owned what.

They really need to chill with the announcements.

Are Saturday races disenfranchising?

I had one other thought about St. George. The race was on Saturday. Given how much crap they now make you do the day before, there’s no way to not take Friday off from work. And if you don’t live within easy driving distance, then there goes Thursday too. You know who can’t take two days off of work easily? Lots of people. People who we are supposedly trying to get into triathlon.

Yes, I know there are racers for whom Sunday races are problematic because of religious conflicts. But that’s also true for some racers on Saturdays. So I think that might be a wash. What I’m not sure is a wash is making the sport accessible by making it a bigger and more costly production?

A solution looking for a problem

We talked on the podcast last week about the Court of Arbitration for Sport’s ruling in the Caster Semenya case, but I realized we didn’t do an amazing job explaining all the background. There’s also been a lot written and said about it both since then and before, so I’m not super eager to rehash. A quick recap and a couple of points:

– The IAAF wants to regulate the amount of testosterone women are allowed to naturally produce in order to compete as women in certain events. Why just certain events? Because they couldn’t prove testosterone had an effect in all events.

– The CAS says they’re allowed to do that. You know, for women’s own good.

– What happened before this became a case centered on one female runner? Well, people with a range “differential sex disorders” existed and competed and no one knew. And yet women’s sports went on. This didn’t suddenly become a biological reality six years ago. There have always been women (and men) who fall somewhere in the scientific range between two ends.

To me there are two major issues with the ruling:

1. Coming up with a sex test for female athletes based on our best science of the time has never panned out well historically, whether that was measuring women’s clits or making them take chromosome tests. I don’t think this bright line will age well either.

2. Even the court noted the practice was discriminatory and they had concerns about practical applications. Yet, they ruled it was necessary discrimination. (Generally, a principle that doesn’t hold up well to history either.) What I think people haven’t really thought through is this: There is no system in place to make every single woman competing at any international level go through testosterone testing and to track that they comply the required six months with the shots to alter their natural testosterone levels. This is actually almost entirely separate from doping controls to be clear. I think most women don’t even know their testosterone levels and some would probably be surprised to find they’re higher than this new “woman limit.” That means enforcement will be case-by-case, and will likely be based on suspicions and on whether or not certain athletes comply with traditional feminine appearances. I think it’s not hard to see how this gets super weird super fast.

I’m sure I could say more, but other things to read if you really want to deep dive:

– The Humiliating Practice of Sex-Testing Female Athletes
– The Myth of Testosterone
– A lot on the flawed science of the ruling (even though I don’t always agree with the guy)
– Caster Semenya is being forced to alter her body to make slower runners feel secure in their womanhood
– Did We Just See Caster Semenya’s Last Race?
– And here’s something I reported on the context and history back before the Rio Olympics: Who Gets to Be a Woman in the Olympics?

_________________

_____________

Comments & thoughts

– Jennifer said it was amazing to be at IM Texas and see Jocelyn leading for so long. And also, Jennifer yelled at me a lot this past weekend, so bonus points.

– Actually a few people came up to introduce themselves and say they look forward to Wednesday mornings. Glad I could do that for Wednesdays.

– The great debate of 2019 over “skipping” v. “jumping rope” is happening and right now I am winning.

86 Responses

  1. Clinton Ewens

    Spot on with this write-up, I actually suppose this web site needs rather more consideration. I’ll in all probability be once more to read far more, thanks for that info.

    Reply
  2. submissive live chat

    That is a really very good go through for me, Should admit that you just are one particular of the best bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative write-up.

    Reply
  3. Citrix 1Y0-240

    That is a really good tip especially to those fresh to the blogosphere. Simple but very accurate info Many thanks for sharing this one. A must read post!

    Reply
  4. best new gadgets 2019

    I’а†ve learn several excellent stuff here. Definitely worth bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how so much effort you place to create such a magnificent informative web site.

    Reply
  5. cisco 3650

    Wow, fantastic blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is fantastic, let alone the content!

    Reply
  6. hoc nghe phun xam tham my

    It is actually a great and helpful piece of information. I am happy that you just shared this useful info with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

    Reply
  7. brcko

    This awesome blog is definitely interesting additionally diverting. I have found a bunch of interesting things out of it. I ad love to return over and over again. Cheers!

    Reply
  8. Google

    Google

    Very couple of sites that happen to be in depth beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out.

    Reply
  9. IVF treatment in India

    You have made some really good points there. I looked on the net for more info about the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this site.

    Reply
  10. Nona

    You made some decent factors there. I regarded on the web for the issue and located most people will go along with with your website.

    Reply
  11. Carina

    magnificent points altogether, you just gained a new reader. What would you suggest about your post that you made some days ago? Any positive?

    Reply
  12. سکس نیمه

    سکس نیمه

    […]that will be the finish of this article. Here you will locate some internet sites that we consider you will enjoy, just click the links over[…]

    Reply
  13. buttocks

    Your style is really unique compared to other people I ave read stuff from. I appreciate you for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I will just bookmark this site.

    Reply
  14. coque iphone

    I recently found Kservice as i searched for it this once i noticed it turned out fondling way up ram. We don’t have Sky. I can only think additionally it is utilised by 4OD i do have and also which will quickly lots upon statup once more without having admission.
    coque iphone https://kgs-florensstrasse.de/?p=7244

    Reply
  15. coque iphone

    Have a look at MyFiveStarMusic. net We locate good music along with now i’m usually changing. Their farely brand new along with Now i am looking to get that off the floor. Book it. Thank you I favor the concept of these types of, nevertheless Exercise including enjoying on the net broadcasts. All it takes is aside the necessity to try to find audio. Only placed this, as well as let it stay in the back.
    coque iphone http://beaumontnailsandspa.net/?p=40096

    Reply
  16. coque iphone

    The actual longer could it be prior to 3 DIMENSIONAL printers are able to use various supplies and they are of enough capability to enable a user for you to creation their unique hand gun…?? (it might probably be done at this point if someone really wants to the particular areas together). I””m worried the particular negative aspects involving THREE-DIMENSIONAL stamping needs to be planned combined with tree-hugging, good-for-the-earth aspects…
    coque iphone https://pt.teles-relay.com/?p=331094

    Reply
  17. coque iphone

    may also help you “Make your current artwork look like garbage. micron Look at his or her created this particular logo design idea with regard to my very own layout business right after experiencing Von Glitscha’s reserve, Vector Basic Coaching. He describes his / her complete innovative procedure coming from sketching hard thumbnails “analog” fashion,
    coque iphone https://www.nc3rs.org.uk/macaques/?p=3770

    Reply
  18. coque iphone

    We all make use of Storage space Server the year 2003 as well as ’08 throughout ESX5. VMware legally isn’t going to help Hard drive Hardware the year 2003 upon ESX5, but it really functions. i actually haven’t acquired almost any efficiency troubles therefore i have never dug all around inside records, although. organic meat become discovering plenty of problems and I easily how to start concerning this. By the things i can see i’m working great. I complete wish to which all of us do the following: – Bring however VMkernel for each networking credit around the VMware sponsor. – Designate only 1 Networking credit card to each VMKernel. – Be sure the brand new VMKernels are usually lively for any ISCSI HBA. – Arranged the actual multipath insurance plan on each ISCSI datastore for you to Spherical Robin the boy wonder.
    coque iphone http://www.digitalworks.fr/blog/?p=721

    Reply
  19. coque iphone

    I actually uncertainty here is the location for this, yet… I have trouble with our present copyright laws, i believe that the best way each of our recent system of government functions the lobby will be the cause of that. Our legal guidelines do not similarly protect anyone, many people only shield the actual pursuits of any loaded several. Exists not really a way to improve how things are? Just what proportion from the human population may be beat up ahead of real change might be sent that occurs? Our own laws happen to be contorted as well as twisted to learn a wealthy fraction. Example: I’m any area inspector. My loved ones did to carry out online surveys if you are regarding 40 years. We certainly have often put money on very competitively sometimes taking a loss to have jobs hoping that we will make our own revenue insurance agencies typically the data so we would have the help long term online surveys and having the ability to accomplish them very easily simply by modernizing exactly what details many of us already had about data file. Now this similar approach to lawmaking which is safeguarding the RIAA is letting the title sector and others which are gathering copies of our own surveys for you to send out them to men and women accepting affidavits with regard to closings using our own benefit their very own profit and taking out all of us from making money for the personal perspire crews in addition to perform. Just what troubles my family almost all about it is, some day, you will have a lawsuit for a customer survey many of us have ages before, that is used for a new later closing next to all of our will and the tennis courts will probably aspect against us all for a task we all don’t actually receives a commission intended for. We now have written a lot of people in government getting assistance in some way simply to get passive format replies or any answer back in any respect. Romans got the idea a great deal better 2150 a long time ago. Good all of us live in some sort of democracy, although My spouse and i anxiety it is far from a good republic. Many of us election to get a team of Republicans or even Democrats within govt, simply to include all of our rules published as well as reformed to learn a loaded small section, through lobbyists financed by and symbolizing the rich few. That similar federal government most of us identified intended for places an affordable top priority around the tendencies with the the greater part, within the belief that abundant people are not considerably more clever and/or a lot more worthwhile compared to the vast majority. I’m reluctant our federal government is becoming more of a good Birth.
    coque iphone http://dercan.ykdsoft.com/?p=3072

    Reply
  20. coque iphone

    Apologies, I was not apparent. Now i’m trying to figure out the particular MASTER OF SCIENCE target iSCSI tax’? Some have got indicated into the MICROSOF COMPANY focus on SW and indicated that functions terribly (usually VMware forums). In past times, We’ve done a little bit benchmarking to get Starwind and HP’s VSA by simply evaluating effectiveness with the 2 . not
    coque iphone https://ilcaudino.it/?p=71226

    Reply
  21. coque iphone

    I had been just wondering, what exactly does the RIAA crew have got because information this Fran acquired or perhaps published new music? And it is Joel actually required to send his computer for the the courtroom intended for check up or even some thing? I am just simply attempting to know how anybody can realize anyone is actually spreading new music with out joining with the particular sharing themselves. I just received the notice through individuals criminals, and I did not actually open it. Now i’m thinking of just simply going to court by myself (I don’t have any choiceI cannot spend! ), and also Now i am merely reef fishing with regard to as much info because i could.
    coque iphone http://www.hqhwzx.com/blog/?p=706

    Reply
  22. coque iphone

    In addition, with regards to carrying out real world backup copies, its absolutely a good suggestion. But that wont assist Yoga exercise mat Honan if the choice and also scarier situation happenned: The undeniable fact that typically the cyberpunks erased his / her equipment is not the particular worst type of which may occur. At the least Yoga exercise mat realized he is hacked a couple of minutes immediately after currently being sacrificed. What if the online hackers had been a lot more devious? They’d get undetectable the belief that he’s hacked along with slowly and gradually collect his personality facts over a long period of the time. Using these confidentially taken identity facts, often the online hackers would have slowly but surely wrecked the lifetime (eg get a loan in his brand, commit violations with his personality, use their bank account like a babouche keep in mind that laundering). It will probably be a lot more tough cure this kind of ‘slow‘ crack. In this kind of option predicament, a back up didn’t conserve the pup. He’ll have a more diabolical difficulty!
    coque iphone https://chicagonewsdaily.com/?p=52558

    Reply
  23. coque iphone

    I absolutely cherished looking at your own personal article. You come to a number of very good factors I had been only hunting for these records for quite a while. Right after 6 hours regarding ongoing Googleing, ultimately I obtained that within your web site. I actually speculate exactly what is the Google’s problem it doesn’t get ranking this type of beneficial web sites nearer to the top. Typically the highest web pages are chock full of waste.
    coque iphone http://www.itc.edu.kh/d01/?p=14260

    Reply
  24. coque iphone

    Apple likes launching their goods not having a number of features blatantly. In order to start being active . of people functions throughout up coming discharge and the ones can buy the modern model. . -= Nabeel’s previous website… How you can administrator account inside self applied published wp blog =-.
    coque iphone http://tohumlukalem.org/tohumlukalemler/?p=4638

    Reply
  25. coque iphone

    Ssangyong- this company that is looking to develop a great deal ofnew modelsin the following years to have a much larger portion with the market share, joined having ShanghaiAutomotive Industries Group in addition to showcased their freshest compact SUV, dubbed C200, in the ParisMotor Indicate a few days ago. The structure ended up being done by Giugiaro mainly because his ItalDesign doing you hair home is at fee with all the appearance from the brand new models being built.
    coque iphone https://blog.glstock.com/?p=10941

    Reply
  26. coque iphone

    You can try this particular reader, is very excellent along with fastYM Scanner Nothing of these kinds of perform throughout model 12. 0. zero. 1102-us. Not only a one one particular, they will just work with your variants. Whatever you folks which can be sending junk email your own web sites, you think you can test to mend this specific?
    coque iphone http://www.arabmediagroup.org/?p=25109

    Reply
  27. coque iphone

    You will find often negatives when comparing an object by various other target., From the above details My spouse and i figure you could have in comparison a apple ipad along with a Atom driven Notebook Well I did not recognize some points which can be not necessarily throughout Apple’s iPad. Though an apple ipad tablet has its restriction, excellent good attributes. It is possible to have there are great efficiency. We can confess ipad tablet will even a great arised just like new iphone 4.
    coque iphone http://demo1.trisindo.co.id/?p=55321

    Reply
  28. coque iphone

    Certainly, Microsoft windows main Neighborhood seems fine. Absolutely no interest in typically the Microsoft windows pc problem, in addition to in the morning even now waiting for Android mobile phone to get unique to get supplements despite the fact that decades awful on mobile phones. WebOS had been ensuring nevertheless it past away an instant demise. iOS is still king connected with tablets in addition to Mac pc OS IN THIS HANDSET X california king involving desktop computer production.
    coque iphone https://www.dasrecht.de/?p=2174

    Reply
  29. coque iphone

    the including Problem is with LG Times note RD400, each week again by mistake a few records or perhaps state several program data or even operators claim removed currently when my spouse and i wordpress tool LAN line notebook will not discover it. You should notify like any owners have to be installed or perhaps what??
    coque iphone http://34.204.51.27/?p=1001

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.